Electric cars at the same price as gas: only 39.0% of US drivers would be likely to choose one, falling to 13.0% at $8,000 more
Price first, but not price alone: in November 2026, 53.5% of US gas and hybrid drivers on Brox's U.S. panel (n=200 clones) named the higher purchase price as the main thing stopping them from buying an electric car, yet only 39.0% would be likely to choose an electric compact SUV over a gas one at the same $35,000 price, and 13.0% at $8,000 more.
- Who was asked
- U.S. nat. rep., 200 clones, US
- When
- November 2026 (fielded 12 November 2026)
- How
- Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
- What changed from the obvious question
- The obvious question gives a list of worries. We asked for the main barrier once, then priced the same electric compact SUV against a $35,000 gas one at $8,000 more, $3,000 more and the same price, each written out in full, and finally asked what would still hold people back at the same price. We asked 200 clones of US adults who drive a gas, diesel or regular hybrid car.
Section 01: What the panel said
- #
39%
39.0% (78) would be likely to choose an electric compact SUV over a gas one at the same $35,000 price, against 27.0% (54) at $3,000 more and 13.0% (26) at $8,000 more.
base 200
- #
53.5%
53.5% (107) named the higher purchase price as the main thing stopping them from buying a fully electric car, ahead of too few public chargers (19.0%, 38), range on long trips (14.5%, 29), battery life and resale value (8.0%, 16) and nowhere to charge at home (5.0%, 10).
base 200
- #
46.7%
46.7% (50 of 107) of the clones who named price as their main barrier were still not likely to choose the electric SUV when it cost the same as the gas one.
base 107 · Named price as the main barrier · contrast
- #
58.3%
58.3% of men (35 of 60) would be likely to choose the electric SUV at the same price, against 30.9% of women (43 of 139).
base 60 · Men · contrast
39.0% (78) would be likely to choose an electric compact SUV over a gas one at the same $35,000 price, against 27.0% (54) at $3,000 more and 13.0% (26) at $8,000 more.
02How much of the market does each step in the price gap take away?
The interesting reading is how early the loss starts. The first $3,000 of premium takes the share likely to choose the electric SUV from 39.0% (78) to 27.0% (54) of 200 clones, so 24 of the 78 clones who were likely at the same price drop away before the gap is even half the size of the old federal credit. The next $5,000 takes it to 13.0% (26). Each $1,000 of the first step costs more buyers than each $1,000 of the second.
What the numbers support: the order of the three prices and the size of the fall. 192 of 200 clones never became more likely to choose the electric SUV as its price rose, and the share very unlikely to choose it went from 38.0% (76) at the same price to 54.5% (109) at $3,000 more and 72.5% (145) at $8,000 more. Where exactly between $3,000 and $8,000 the market tips was not measured.
03Why does matching the price not win over most drivers?
Matching the price moves a real group: 25.5% (51) of the 200 clones were unlikely to choose the electric SUV at $8,000 more and likely at the same price. It still leaves 57.0% (114) unlikely, and close to half of the clones who named price as their main barrier stay unlikely once the price is equal.
The interesting reading is what takes the place of price. Asked what would still make them choose gas at the same price, battery life and resale value came first at 38.5% (77), ahead of range on long trips at 17.5% (35) and nowhere to charge at home at 11.0% (22), while 31.0% (62) said nothing would. What the numbers support is narrower: every one of those answers was inferred from each person's wider interview rather than from something they said about electric cars, so we read the order as a direction, not a ranking.
04Who is closest to buying an electric car?
Income matters most when the gap is wide. At $8,000 more, 27.5% of clones in households earning $100,000 or more (11 of 40) would be likely to choose the electric SUV, against 8.6% of those earning under $50,000 (8 of 93). At the same price the difference narrows to 52.5% (21 of 40) against 35.5% (33 of 93).
05What would a carmaker or energy company do with this?
- A reading, not the panel's answer: money spent closing the last $3,000 of a price gap moves more buyers per dollar than the same money spent on a wider gap.
- A reading: once the price matches, the next objection is the battery, so a long battery warranty or a guaranteed resale value speaks to the drivers who are left, where more public chargers alone may not.
- A reading: households earning $100,000 or more are the market a wide price gap leaves standing, and the one to test first.
06What else do people ask about electric cars and price?
- What share of US drivers would choose an electric car at the same price as a gas one? In November 2026, 39.0% (78) of 200 clones of US gas and hybrid drivers were likely to choose an electric compact SUV at the same $35,000 price as a gas one.
- At what price gap do most US drivers rule out an electric car? At $3,000 more, 54.5% (109) of 200 clones were very unlikely to choose the electric SUV, rising to 72.5% (145) at $8,000 more.
- How many US drivers say price is the main thing stopping them from buying an electric car? 53.5% (107) of 200 clones named the higher purchase price, ahead of too few public chargers at 19.0% (38) and range on long trips at 14.5% (29).
Section 07: What they said, and the interview line it rests on
“If they're both the exact same price at $35,000, with the same size and quality, I would be very likely to go with the electric model. I've said before that if I ever actually buy a car, I hope it will be an electric vehicle. The only real barrier for me has always been the price differential, because right now I have to go with whatever is economically feasible. But if the upfront cost is identical, the electric car makes a lot more sense economically in the long run. Gas prices fluctuate wildly and can get horrifyingly expensive to fill up a tank, whereas with an electric vehicle, you can just plug it in at home and they supposedly pay for themselves over time. So if the purchase price is tied, there's really no reason not to choose the EV.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“Well, it would still depend on the price differential between a gas-powered vehicle and an electric vehicle. I honestly have to, like most Americans, have to go with what's more economically feasible at the moment.”
“For us, the primary reason is simply the cost. Electric vehicles are much more expensive than the options we've chosen, and there's just no reason for us to spend extra money when our current vehicles do the job dependably. While I might also have a bit of nervousness about whether an EV has enough power for a long-distance trip or finding charging stations, the bottom line is that the higher purchase price is the main thing holding us back.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“So the main reason we don't buy them is because they're more expensive.”
“I would be very unlikely to choose the electric model. Honestly, I wouldn't even give buying an EV serious thought until maybe in the next decade. There are just too many factors to worry about right now, especially whether our electrical grid can handle it. On top of that, I live in a place where winters get well below zero, and extreme cold is brutal on batteries and cars in general. I'm also a mechanic, so I know how traditional gas vehicles work and how to fix them. If I had to pick between the two today at thirty-five thousand, I'd go with the gas SUV without question.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“Intend to buy, I would give it a serious thought maybe in the next decade, depending on prices, depending on our electrical grid. And, well, there's a lot of factors.”
Section 08: How much should you trust this?
What we would defend
- The order and the size of the fall across the three prices: 192 of 200 clones never became more likely to choose the electric SUV as its price rose, and the answers at each price reason from that price (the $8,000 figure appears in 199 of 200 answers at that price).
- Price as the barrier named most often: it leads among all 200 clones and among the 25 whose answer rests on what they said about electric cars in their own interview (13 of 25).
- The split between men and women at the same price, on bases of 60 and 139.
What we would not
- Where exactly the market tips between $3,000 and $8,000: the study priced three points, not a curve.
- The order of what would still hold people back at the same price (battery life and resale value 77 of 200): every one of those 200 answers was inferred from wider interviews, and too few public chargers fell from 38 of 200 as the main barrier in general to 4 of 200 at the same price, a shift the reasoning does not explain.
- Any figure for drivers aged 18 to 29 (9 clones) or for drivers of regular hybrids (10 clones).
- A real-world adoption rate: the two cars were identical apart from drivetrain and price, with no running costs, incentives, financing or brand named.
The main limitation
The panel as fielded skews female (139 of 200) and older (134 of 200 aged 45 or over), and men were far more willing, so a panel with as many men as women would put the same-price figure higher. Most answers (175 of 200 on the barrier question, 191 of 200 at the same price) are inferred from each person's wider interview rather than something they said about electric cars.
Section 09: How was this run?
| Segment | Clones |
|---|---|
| Aged 18-29 | 9 |
| Aged 30-44 | 57 |
| Aged 45-64 | 88 |
| Aged 65 and over | 46 |
| Women | 139 |
| Men | 60 |
Question wording as fielded
- Which best describes the car you drive most often today?
- In general, what is the main thing that stops you from buying a fully electric car?
- Imagine you are buying your next car and choosing between two new compact SUVs that are the same in size, features and quality: a gas model at $35,000 and a fully electric model with 300 miles of range at $43,000, which is $8,000 more. How likely would you be to choose the electric model?
- Imagine you are buying your next car and choosing between two new compact SUVs that are the same in size, features and quality: a gas model at $35,000 and a fully electric model with 300 miles of range at $38,000, which is $3,000 more. How likely would you be to choose the electric model?
- Imagine you are buying your next car and choosing between two new compact SUVs that are the same in size, features and quality: a gas model at $35,000 and a fully electric model with 300 miles of range, also at $35,000, the same price. How likely would you be to choose the electric model?
- If a new fully electric compact SUV cost exactly the same as the gas version, what would be the main reason you might still choose the gas one?
What was not asked, and why
We did not ask about running costs, fuel or electricity prices, incentives, financing or leasing, used electric cars or any brand, and listed no brands. Drivers of plug-in hybrids or fully electric cars and people who do not drive were screened out (87 of 500).
What changed from the obvious question
The obvious question gives a list of worries. We asked for the main barrier once, then priced the same electric compact SUV against a $35,000 gas one at $8,000 more, $3,000 more and the same price, each written out in full, and finally asked what would still hold people back at the same price. We asked 200 clones of US adults who drive a gas, diesel or regular hybrid car.
Fielded through Ask Brox on 12 November 2026.
More on Electric cars and charging · Energy & utilities · U.S. nat. rep. (US) panel
Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai