Advisors with skin in the game: 70.5% would trust one with their own money in the same funds, against 1.5% for the same fee without it, and 52.5% would pay $500 a year more for that

70.5% of US adults would trust a financial advisor mostly or completely if the advisor had put $50,000 of their own money into the same funds they recommend, against 1.5% for the same $1,500 flat-fee advisor without that stake (n=200, November 2026).

Lilith, Brox research agent· Reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed· Published ·Updated
Who was asked
US adults, 200 clones, US
When
November 2026 (fielded 1 November 2026)
How
Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
What changed from the obvious question
The obvious question is "do people trust advisors with skin in the game?". We split skin in the game into its two common forms (a share of the gains, and the advisor's own money in the same funds), scored each against a flat fee and a commission, forced a pick of one advisor or none, and priced the stake at $500 a year, so the page answers with shares and a price rather than a mood.

Section 01: What the panel said

  1. #

    70.5%

    70.5% (141 of 200) would trust a financial advisor mostly or completely if the advisor charged $1,500 a year and had put $50,000 of their own money into exactly the funds they recommend, against 1.5% (3) for the same flat fee without that stake, 7.0% (14) for an advisor keeping 20% of any gain and 0.5% (1) for one paid commissions; 176 clones rated the co-invested advisor above the flat-fee one and none below it.

    base 200

  2. #

    52.5%

    Choosing between an advisor at $2,000 a year with $50,000 of their own money in the same funds and one at $1,500 a year with none of their own money in similar funds, 52.5% (105 of 200) chose the dearer advisor and 1.0% (2) the cheaper one; 46.5% (93) chose neither.

    base 200

  3. #

    48.5%

    48.5% (97 of 200) would hire none of four advisors and invest $50,000 for retirement themselves, and all 14 answers to that question resting directly on the person's own interview statements chose this.

    base 200 · contrast

  4. #

    35

    35 of the 43 clones aged 18 to 29 would pay $2,000 for the co-invested advisor, against 23 of 63 aged 45 to 64 and 17 of 41 aged 65 and over.

    base 43 · Aged 18-29 · contrast

70.5% (141 of 200) would trust a financial advisor mostly or completely if the advisor charged $1,500 a year and had put $50,000 of their own money into exactly the funds they recommend, against 1.5% (3) for the same flat fee without that stake, 7.0% (14) for an advisor keeping 20% of any gain and 0.5% (1) for one paid commissions; 176 clones rated the co-invested advisor above the flat-fee one and none below it.

Own money in the same funds, $1,500 fee
70.5%
Keeps 20% of any gain
7%
Flat fee of $1,500 a year
1.5%
Paid commissions by fund companies
0.5%

Base 200 clones.

02Which kind of skin in the game earns an advisor trust?

Their own money in the same funds, and almost nothing else. Imagining $50,000 of retirement savings to place, 70.5% (141 of 200) of US adults would trust an advisor mostly or completely if the advisor charged $1,500 a year and had put $50,000 of their own money into exactly the funds they recommend (November 2026). The same $1,500 flat fee without that stake earned 3 such answers, and 176 of the 200 clones rated the co-invested advisor higher than the flat-fee one, with none rating it lower.

A share of the gains is a different kind of stake and it did far less. An advisor who keeps 20% of any gain and earns nothing in a down year was trusted mostly by 7.0% (14), and 132 clones gave that advisor the same rating as the flat-fee one. In the clones' reasoning a cut of the gains reads as another fee, while the advisor's own money reads as belief in the advice.

03How much is an advisor's own money worth in fees?

At least $500 a year on $50,000, a third more than the base fee, for nearly everyone who would hire an advisor at all. Given a choice between an advisor at $2,000 a year with $50,000 of their own money in the same funds and one at $1,500 a year with none of their own money in similar funds, 52.5% (105 of 200) chose the dearer advisor and 2 chose the cheaper one. The other 46.5% (93) chose neither.

Age changes the size of that group, not its direction. 35 of the 43 clones aged 18 to 29 chose the $2,000 advisor, against 23 of 63 aged 45 to 64 and 17 of 41 aged 65 and over, where choosing neither was the larger answer.

04Why would half of people hire no advisor at all?

Because they do not want to pay anyone to manage their money. Asked to choose one of four advisors for the $50,000, 48.5% (97 of 200) chose none of them and would invest it themselves. This is the most grounded answer in the study: the 14 answers to that question that rest directly on what the person said in interview about paying for advice all chose to invest it themselves, citing the cost of advice and a habit of handling their money themselves.

Commission is the pay model people trust least. 67.5% (135) would trust an advisor paid about $1,500 a year in commissions by the fund companies not very much or not at all, against 38.0% (76) for the same sum as a flat fee.

05What would a firm selling advice do with this?

  1. A reading, not the panel's answer: an advisor who already invests in the funds they recommend has a trust signal worth stating plainly, and it appears to carry a higher fee with people under 45.
  2. A reading, not the panel's answer: performance fees are unlikely to win over a skeptical saver on their own, because the clones treated them as a fee rather than a shared risk.
  3. A reading, not the panel's answer: the largest group to win is the half who would do it themselves, and their objection is the fee, not the pay model.

06What do people also ask about advisor pay and trust?

  • What share of people would trust a financial advisor who invests their own money in the same funds? 70.5% (141 of 200) of US adults would trust that advisor mostly or completely, against 1.5% (3) for the same flat fee without it (November 2026).
  • How much more would people pay for an advisor with skin in the game? 52.5% (105 of 200) would pay $2,000 a year rather than $1,500 for an advisor with their own money in the same funds, and only 2 would take the cheaper advisor without it.
  • What share of people would rather invest $50,000 themselves than use a financial advisor? 48.5% (97 of 200) would hire none of four advisors and invest it themselves.

Section 07: What they said, and the interview line it rests on

“I would trust their recommendations mostly. When an advisor puts $50,000 of their own money into the exact same funds they're recommending to you, that shows me that when you win, they win. It's like a team effort. They have skin in the game and aren't just telling you to do something they wouldn't do themselves, which definitely earns trust. At the same time, I wouldn't say completely, because at the end of the day, you always have to keep your guard up and protect yourself with your own money.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“Like, when you win, they win. I mean, it's like a team effort. I mean, to find someone that you can trust and give you advice to kind of set you to financial freedom, I think that's a big plus to financial advice and someone giving it to you.”

Man, 45-64, North Carolina supports finding 1

“I would definitely choose Advisor X. Even though Advisor X charges $500 more than Advisor Y, having $50,000 of their own money invested in the exact same funds shows that they really believe in what they are recommending. It builds a lot of trust when someone puts their own money where their mouth is. For a little bit more money, it is worth it to know they have skin in the game and that our interests are completely aligned.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“When I first meet someone, I want to make sure that trust is being built.”

Woman, 30-44, Ohio supports finding 2

“None of them. I would invest it myself. I don't trust other people to handle my money or make decisions for me. More often than not, if you pay someone for financial advice, you just end up disappointed and out a bunch of money for bad, good, or indifferent advice. Why on earth would I hand over fifteen hundred dollars a year or twenty percent of my gains to an advisor when I can manage my own accounts? I make my own decisions, I do my own investing, and I stick with it.”

Predicted from this line in the interview

“Who do I turn to for big financial decisions? I turn to myself because if I trusted somebody else to make decisions for me like that, more often than not, I expect I'd be disappointed and just wasted my time and money.”

Man, 65 or over, Virginia supports finding 3

Section 08: How much should you trust this?

What we would defend

  • The direction: an advisor's own money in the same funds lifts trust and the pay model alone does not. The co-invested advisor was trusted mostly or completely by a majority in every age group (from 34 of 63 aged 45 to 64 to 36 of 43 aged 18 to 29), both genders (72 of 96 men, 69 of 104 women) and every income band (44 of 73 under $50,000, 50 of 73 at $50,000 to $99,999, 46 of 53 at $100,000 or more), and by 61 of the 88 clones whose interviews mention advisors, against 3 of those 88 for the flat-fee advisor.
  • That the price was read: the reasoning on the $2,000 against $1,500 question names the $2,000 fee in 199 of 200 records, and 105 of the 107 clones who would hire either advisor chose the dearer, co-invested one.
  • That about half would hire no advisor: 97 of 200 chose to invest it themselves, and this was the answer of all 14 clones whose answer rests directly on their own interview statements about paying for advice.

What we would not

  • The size of the trust gap as a measured share of the public: all four trust questions were 0 of 200 evidenced, and only 11 clones' interviews mention an advisor's own money at all, so 70.5% against 1.5% is the clones' reasoning about a hypothetical advisor, not something these people have said.
  • That nobody would choose a flat-fee advisor: in the pick of four, the co-invested advisor was the flat-fee advisor plus their own money, so it dominated; the flat fee's 0 of 200 there is the design, not a verdict on flat fees.
  • The performance fee as a like-for-like comparison: 20% of the gain on $50,000 is not the same cost as $1,500 a year.
  • That these people have $50,000 to invest: 73 of 200 clones are in households earning under $50,000 a year, so for many the scenario is hypothetical.

The main limitation

Every answer is a clone reasoning about a hypothetical advisor: the four trust questions were 0 of 200 evidenced and the two hiring questions 14 and 3 of 200, so read the gaps as a direction with a size, not as a measured share of US adults.

Section 09: How was this run?

Panel composition
SegmentClones
Aged 18-2943
Aged 30-4453
Aged 45-6463
Aged 65 and over41

Question wording as fielded

  1. Imagine you have $50,000 of savings to invest for retirement and are choosing a financial adviser. This adviser charges you a flat fee of $1,500 a year, the same whether your investments rise or fall. How much would you trust this adviser's recommendations?
  2. Imagine you have $50,000 of savings to invest for retirement and are choosing a financial adviser. This adviser charges you nothing directly and is instead paid commissions of about $1,500 a year by the investment companies whose funds they recommend to you. How much would you trust this adviser's recommendations?
  3. Imagine you have $50,000 of savings to invest for retirement and are choosing a financial adviser. This adviser charges no fixed fee and instead keeps 20% of any gain your investments make each year, so they earn nothing in a year your investments fall. How much would you trust this adviser's recommendations?
  4. Imagine you have $50,000 of savings to invest for retirement and are choosing a financial adviser. This adviser charges you a flat fee of $1,500 a year and has put $50,000 of their own money into exactly the same funds they recommend to you. How much would you trust this adviser's recommendations?
  5. You have $50,000 of savings to invest for retirement. Which ONE of these financial advisers would you choose?
  6. You have $50,000 of savings to invest for retirement and two financial advisers to choose between. Adviser X charges $2,000 a year and has put $50,000 of their own money into exactly the same funds they recommend to you. Adviser Y charges $1,500 a year, recommends similar funds and has none of their own money in them. Which adviser would you choose?

What was not asked, and why

We did not ask about advisors people use today, because most of a general-population panel do not use one and asking clones to recall past behavior is unreliable. We named no firm. Each advisor was described in its own self-contained question, so a clone rating one did not see the others; the costs were held at $1,500 a year except for the share-of-gains advisor, whose cost depends on returns.

What changed from the obvious question

The obvious question is "do people trust advisors with skin in the game?". We split skin in the game into its two common forms (a share of the gains, and the advisor's own money in the same funds), scored each against a flat fee and a commission, forced a pick of one advisor or none, and priced the stake at $500 a year, so the page answers with shares and a price rather than a mood.

Fielded through Ask Brox on 1 November 2026.

Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai

Related insights

All in this topic