Ad-free streaming holds at a $3 premium over the plan with ads and breaks by $6: 68.4% of US ad-free subscribers stay at $3, 43.2% at $6, and 23.2% at $9
US streaming subscribers switch from ad-free to the plan with ads between a $3 and a $6 monthly gap: of those paying for ad-free today, 68.4% would keep it at $3 more than a $12.99 plan with ads, 43.2% at $6 more and 23.2% at $9 more (n=95 ad-free subscribers in a panel of 200 streaming payers, September 2026).
- Who was asked
- US ad-free subscribers, 200 clones, US
- When
- September 2026 (fielded 25 September 2026)
- How
- Predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person.
- What changed from the obvious question
- Rather than asking what price is too high for ad-free, we held the plan with ads at $12.99 and showed three fully written pairs with the ad-free plan $3, $6 and $9 dearer, so the answer is the gap at which people move, and whether they move to ads or leave.
Section 01: What the panel said
- #
24%
The share of US streaming subscribers choosing ad-free falls from 40.5% at a $3 gap over a $12.99 plan with ads to 24.0% at $6 and 12.0% at $9
base 200
- #
43.2%
Of subscribers on an ad-free plan today, 68.4% would keep it at a $3 gap, 43.2% at $6 and 23.2% at $9
base 95 · On an ad-free plan today
- #
15%
Canceling barely moves with the gap (17.0% at $3, 20.5% at $9): 15.0% cancel at every gap, mostly subscribers already on a plan with ads for whom $12.99 is too much
base 200 · contrast
- #
72%
72.0% say a bigger monthly saving would do most to make them accept ads, but among ad-free subscribers 32.6% would rather have ads only before a show starts
base 200 · contrast
The share of US streaming subscribers choosing ad-free falls from 40.5% at a $3 gap over a $12.99 plan with ads to 24.0% at $6 and 12.0% at $9
02Where is the price gap at which ad-free stops being worth it?
Somewhere between $3 and $6 a month. We held the plan with ads at $12.99 and raised the ad-free plan in three steps, each written out in full: $15.99, $18.99 and $21.99. At a $3 gap 40.5% of all 200 subscribers chose ad-free; at $6 that fell to 24.0%, and at $9 to 12.0% (n=200). The biggest single step down is the first one, from $3 to $6.
The people who move are the ones paying for ad-free today. Of the 95 on an ad-free plan, 65 would keep it at a $3 gap, 41 at $6 and 22 at $9. The 103 already on a plan with ads hardly ever trade up: 15 would at $3, 7 at $6 and 2 at $9.
03Why does this matter after this month's price increases?
After the September 2026 increases, the ad-free plans on some large services cost about $9 a month more than the same service with ads. That is the widest gap we tested, and at it only 23.2% of today's ad-free subscribers say they would stay ad-free (22 of 95). Most of the rest say they would move to the plan with ads rather than leave.
The more cautious reading is that these are stated choices. Real subscribers are slower to change plan than they say, and one of the ad-free holdouts told us it is simply too much of a hassle to cancel and start again. Read the percentages as the direction and size of the pressure, not as a forecast of switching.
04Who cancels instead of switching, and is it the gap that pushes them?
Mostly not. Canceling barely moves as the gap widens: 17.0% at $3, 18.0% at $6 and 20.5% at $9 (n=200). Thirty subscribers cancel at every gap, and 29 of the 34 who would cancel at $3 are already on a plan with ads. In their own words, $12.99 for the plan with ads is already above what they will pay, usually around $10. For this group the problem is the price of the cheaper plan, not the premium on the dearer one.
05What would make an ad plan easier to accept?
Money first. Asked for the one change that would do most, 72.0% chose a bigger monthly saving over the ad-free plan (144 of 200). Among today's ad-free subscribers the answer is less one-sided: 52 of 95 chose the saving, and 31 of 95 chose ads only before a show starts, never during it. Only 8 of 200 said nothing would make them accept ads.
- A reading, not the panel's answer: for a service trying to hold ad-free subscribers who are thinking of trading down, an ads plan without mid-show breaks may do more than a deeper discount.
- A second reading: a service that wants to stop cancellations rather than downgrades needs a cheaper entry plan, because widening or narrowing the ad-free premium barely touches the people who leave.
Section 06: What they said, and the interview line it rests on
“I would definitely go with the plan with ads at $12.99 a month. Honestly, charging extra just to not have advertisements feels like a bit of a racket, so I don't really like paying more just to get rid of them. Plus, saving that $6 a month is a big plus for me. I really don't mind ads at all—in fact, having a few ad breaks gives me a chance to step away, fold laundry, use the bathroom, or grab a snack. Four minutes an hour is barely anything anyway, so saving money and having those little breaks makes the ad plan totally worth it to me.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“I do not really like when they do more expensive for no advertisements. It just seems like it's kind of a racket and they're just trying to make more money.”
“I would choose the ad-free plan at $21.99 a month. For me, it is well worth the extra money not to have to sit through ads while watching my shows or movies. Ads are just boring and ruin the experience. I have kept the same streaming services for years because watching is one of my favorite things to do to relax, and I really don't like the hassle of canceling or changing things up. Even if the price goes up, I'd rather just pay the difference to keep it ad-free.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“I really like the fact that it's ad free. It's well worth the money not to have to watch the ads that come along with the videos. Sometimes they're boring ads.”
“Honestly, I would cancel the service. The absolute most I would ever pay for a streaming service is $10 a month. Right now, I pay less than $8 a month for one and around $100 for the whole year for another, and I never run out of things to watch on the two of them. I feel like $6 to $10 is a fair price, so both $12.99 and $15.99 are just more than I am willing to spend. I'm very frugal with my money, and I don't pay extra for things I don't need—I'm certainly not interested in paying extra just for an ad-free experience. If a company raises their rates and isn't competitive with their prices, I'm not going to stay with them just for the sake of staying, so I would just cancel.”
Predicted from this line in the interview
“I would say in the six to $10 range per month is a fair price”
Section 07: How much should you trust this?
What we would defend
- The ad-free share roughly halves from a $3 to a $6 gap and halves again at $9, on the same 200 streaming payers, with each price level written out in full and reasoned on its own figures.
- The move comes from today's ad-free subscribers (65, 41 and 22 of 95 keep ad-free), not from people already on a plan with ads.
- Cancellation is flat across the gaps and is driven by the $12.99 price of the plan with ads.
What we would not
- An exact dollar tipping point: only three gaps were tested, so the answer is a range, $3 to $6.
- Any forecast of real switching rates: these are stated choices, and real subscribers change plan more slowly than they say.
- Any cut by age: only 8 of the 200 are aged 18 to 29.
The main limitation
Stated choices on a hypothetical service with a fixed $12.99 plan with ads; the panel leans female (132 of 200) and aged 45 to 64 (101 of 200).
Section 08: How was this run?
| Segment | Clones |
|---|---|
| On an ad-free plan today | 95 |
| On a plan with ads today | 103 |
| Not sure which plan | 2 |
Question wording as fielded
- Do you currently pay for at least one video streaming subscription (a service such as a film and TV streaming service you pay for monthly or yearly)?
- On the video streaming service you pay the most for, which plan are you on?
- Your main streaming service offers two plans: an ad-free plan at $15.99 a month, and a plan with about four minutes of ads per hour at $12.99 a month, so going ad-free costs $3 a month more. Which would you choose?
- Your main streaming service offers two plans: an ad-free plan at $18.99 a month, and a plan with about four minutes of ads per hour at $12.99 a month, so going ad-free costs $6 a month more. Which would you choose?
- Your main streaming service offers two plans: an ad-free plan at $21.99 a month, and a plan with about four minutes of ads per hour at $12.99 a month, so going ad-free costs $9 a month more. Which would you choose?
- Which one change would do most to make you accept a streaming plan with ads?
What was not asked, and why
No brand was named and no service was asked about by name. We did not vary the price of the plan with ads, the ad load (fixed at about four minutes an hour) or annual pricing, and did not ask what subscribers do today on a real service.
What changed from the obvious question
Rather than asking what price is too high for ad-free, we held the plan with ads at $12.99 and showed three fully written pairs with the ad-free plan $3, $6 and $9 dearer, so the answer is the gap at which people move, and whether they move to ads or leave.
Fielded through Ask Brox on 25 September 2026.
More on Streaming prices, tiers and ads · Streaming & entertainment · Streaming (US) panel
Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai
Related insights
All in this topic-
Streaming price rises in Turkey: 84.5% of paying households keep their plan at +20%, 63.5% at +40% and 52.0% at +60%, and most who leave switch to a rival
84.5% Asked what they would do if the 300 TL monthly plan on the streaming service they use most went up, 84.5% of paying households would keep the plan at a 20% rise, 63.5% at 40% and 52.0% at 60% (base 200)
Read -
Free ad-supported TV is a weekly habit for 33.5% of Americans, but only 6 in 200 make it their main screen, and price is the main pull
33.5% 33.5% watch free ad-supported streaming at least once a week (67 of 200), while 39.0% never do. (base 200)
Read -
94% of US adults would wait as long as it takes for a film to reach streaming rather than go to the movies, and the few who do go, go for the company
94% 94% of US adults would wait as long as it takes for a film to reach a streaming service they already pay for rather than go to the movies; 5 of 200 would go rather than wait (base 200)
Read -
None of 33 US music listeners would pay $3 or $7 a month more for a lossless tier, 32 of 33 have never compared it with standard quality, and only 9 of 33 pay for music streaming at all
0 None of the 33 would move to a lossless, hi-fi tier at $14.99 a month, $3 more than their $11.99 plan: 30 of 33 would stay on the current plan and 3 of 33 would look for a service that includes lossless at no extra charge. At $18.99, $7 more, 33 of 33 would stay. (base 33)
Read