# When an accountant's mistake loses the client in Great Britain: 69.5% would stay after a £100 error, 3.7% after £500, and passing on their details ends trust as often as the £500 loss

*What breaks trust in a professional adviser, and how big a mistake makes clients leave?*

In November 2026, the mistake that costs an accountant a client in Great Britain lies between £100 and £500: of 164 clones on Brox's UK panel, 69.5% would keep an accountant who charges £300 a year after a mistake costing them £100, against 3.7% after one costing £500 (n=164).

- **Who was asked:** UK adults, 164 clones, GB
- **When:** fielded 2026-11-15
- **How:** predicted responses from Brox clones, each built from a long-form interview with a real person
- **What changed from the obvious question:** The obvious question is "what breaks trust in an adviser?", which invites a list of virtues. We asked 164 clones on our UK panel to pick the one failure out of four that would most end it, then priced an accountant's mistake at £100, £500 and £2,000 against a £300 yearly fee in three separate, self-contained questions, and asked whether a refund or an explanation does more to keep the client. So the page answers with a threshold and a trade-off rather than a list.
- **Author:** Lilith, Brox research agent · **Reviewed:** Lilith, AI reviewed · **Published:** 2026-11-15
- **Canonical:** https://reports.brox.ai/insights/accountant-mistake-threshold-gb-70-percent-stay-after-100-pounds-4-percent-after-500

## What the panel said

1. **69.5%** 69.5% (114 of 164) would keep an accountant who charges £300 a year after a mistake costing them £100, falling to 3.7% (6 of 164) after one costing £500 and 0.6% (1 of 164) after one costing £2,000, each time with an apology. — base 164 (https://reports.brox.ai/insights/accountant-mistake-threshold-gb-70-percent-stay-after-100-pounds-4-percent-after-500#f1)
2. **43.3%** 43.3% (71 of 164) name an adviser passing their personal details to another firm without asking as the failure that would most make them stop using the adviser, level with a mistake costing £500 at 42.1% (69); 14.6% (24) name a commission taken without telling them, and none a missed deadline. — base 164 (https://reports.brox.ai/insights/accountant-mistake-threshold-gb-70-percent-stay-after-100-pounds-4-percent-after-500#f2)
3. **52.4%** 52.4% (86 of 164) say paying back the £500 would do most to keep them after a £500 mistake, against 29.3% (48) for a written apology explaining what went wrong and what has changed; 18.3% (30) say nothing would keep them. — base 164, contrast (https://reports.brox.ai/insights/accountant-mistake-threshold-gb-70-percent-stay-after-100-pounds-4-percent-after-500#f3)
4. **6** 6 of 164 clones pay a professional adviser today, so almost every answer is from people imagining an adviser rather than recalling one. — base 164, caveat (https://reports.brox.ai/insights/accountant-mistake-threshold-gb-70-percent-stay-after-100-pounds-4-percent-after-500#f4)

Chart — 69.5% (114 of 164) would keep an accountant who charges £300 a year after a mistake costing them £100, falling to 3.7% (6 of 164) after one costing £500 and 0.6% (1 of 164) after one costing £2,000, each time with an apology.:

- £100 mistake: would keep them: 69.5%
- £500 mistake: would keep them: 3.7%
- £2,000 mistake: would keep them: 0.6%

## Why does a £500 mistake end it when a £100 one does not?

The same clones moved together. 108 of 164 would keep the accountant after a £100 mistake and switch after a £500 one, and no clone switched at a smaller mistake and then stayed at a larger one. The jump is steep: from 30.5% switching at £100 to 96.3% at £500 (n=164).

The interesting reading is that the line sits where the mistake overtakes the fee. 157 of the 158 clones who would switch at £500 set it against the £300 they pay, and many say a mistake that costs more than the service defeats the point of hiring a professional. What the numbers support is narrower: the line is somewhere between £100 and £500, because we tested those amounts and not the ones in between.

> **The threshold**
>
> A mistake smaller than the yearly fee is mostly forgiven; a mistake larger than it is almost never forgiven, apology or not.

## Is passing on a client's details really as bad as losing them £500?

In this panel, yes. Passing personal details to another firm without asking (43.3%) and a mistake costing £500 (42.1%) were picked almost equally as the failure that would most end the relationship, and the tie holds for women (35 and 40 of 86) and men (26 and 26 of 65). A commission taken without telling the client came a distant third at 14.6%, and nobody picked a missed deadline first (n=164).

The two groups want different things afterwards. Of the 69 clones whose breaking point is the £500 mistake, 52 say paying the money back would do most to keep them. Of the 71 whose breaking point is the shared details, 34 would rather have a written explanation of what went wrong. The interesting reading: people who think of trust as money want the money back, and people who think of it as conduct want to hear what has changed.

## Who wants an explanation rather than a refund?

Men and clones aged 30 to 44 split more evenly. 25 of 65 men chose the written explanation against 31 who chose the refund, while women chose the refund by 47 to 19 of 86. Clones aged 30 to 44 chose the refund by 25 to 22 of 57; those aged 18 to 29 by 45 to 20 of 81.

The clones who say nothing would keep them are mostly the ones who had already walked at £100: 26 of the 30. The clones who chose the explanation are the forgiving ones, 44 of 48 having kept the accountant at £100.

## What would an accountancy or advisory firm do with this?

1. A reading, not the panel's answer: set the remedy for an error against the fee. Below the fee, an apology does most of the work; above it, the money has to come back, and an explanation keeps a further minority.
2. A second reading: treat data handling as part of the service clients judge, not as compliance in the background. In this panel a leak of personal details ends a client relationship as often as a costly error.

## What do people also ask?

- **What share of clients would leave an accountant over a £500 mistake?** 96.3% of 164 clones on Brox's UK panel would switch accountant after a £500 mistake on a £300-a-year tax return, even with an apology (November 2026).
- **How many clients would forgive an accountant a £100 mistake?** 69.5% (114 of 164) would keep the accountant after a mistake costing them £100.
- **What share of clients would rather have their money back than an explanation?** 52.4% (86 of 164) say paying back the £500 would do most to keep them, against 29.3% (48) for a written explanation of what went wrong.

## What they said, and the interview line it rests on

> “I think I would probably switch to another accountant. While I understand that mistakes can happen and I appreciate an apology, paying £300 for a service only for it to cost me £500 in penalties and extra tax defeats the purpose of hiring a professional to get it right. I value accuracy and attention to detail, especially when it comes to finances and accounting. Much like when a service provider lets me down or charges me more than what was fair, I wouldn't make a scene or hold hard feelings, but my reaction would simply be that I probably wouldn't use them again next year and would look for an alternative.”
>
> *Predicted from this line in the interview:* “And the reaction I have is that probably I won't go to that repairer again.”
>
> — Man, 45-64, Yorkshire and the Humber · supports f1

> “For me, the biggest deal breaker would be if they passed my personal details to another firm without asking me. I consider myself a man of integrity, and when I hire a professional adviser, whether an accountant or a solicitor, there has to be mutual trust and respect. Sharing my private information without my consent completely violates that professional relationship and trust. A mistake or even a missed deadline can sometimes be managed or sorted out, and money can be made back, but once someone breaches confidentiality and integrity like that, I would withdraw my business immediately.”
>
> *Predicted from this line in the interview:* “their customer service relationship. If it depreciates, definitely I will have to withdraw my customership.”
>
> — Man, 30-44 · supports f2

> “Definitely paying me back the £500. At the end of the day, money is tight and I can't just be sitting there out of pocket by £500 because of someone else's mistake. An apology is nice and all, but words don't pay the bill, do they? If they just step up, refund and cover that £500 so I'm not left taking the financial hit, that's what matters most to me to sort it out.”
>
> *Predicted from this line in the interview:* “So, again, they offered us a refund, and they, you know, they were very, very good about it.”
>
> — Woman, 18-29, East Midlands · supports f3

## How much should you trust this?

**What we would defend**

- The threshold between £100 and £500. The same clones moved together: 108 of 164 kept the accountant at £100 and switched at £500, and none switched at a smaller mistake and stayed at a larger one. It holds in every group large enough to read: kept at £100 by 57 of 86 women and 46 of 65 men, 51 of 81 aged 18-29 and 41 of 57 aged 30-44; switched at £500 by 81 of 86 women and 65 of 65 men.
- That each amount was read: the reasoning names its own amount in 162 of 164 answers at £100 and in 164 of 164 at £500 and at £2,000, and 157 of the 158 clones who would switch at £500 set the mistake against the £300 fee.
- The order of the four failures: passing on details and a £500 mistake level, a hidden commission well behind, a missed deadline nobody's first pick. The tie holds for women (35 and 40 of 86) and men (26 and 26 of 65).

**What we would not**

- Exactly where between £100 and £500 the line sits: we tested three amounts, not the ones in between.
- 96.3% switching at £500 and 99.4% at £2,000 as precise shares: near-unanimous answers to a hypothetical read as a direction, not a measurement.
- That a missed deadline does not matter: it was nobody's first pick out of four, which says it ranks below the other three, not that it is harmless.
- That 52.4% would stay if refunded: the question asked which response would do most to keep them, not whether they would then stay.
- Anything about people who use an adviser today: 6 of 164 do, too few to read on their own.

**The main limitation:** Every answer is inferred: Ask Brox rated 0 of 164 answers on each question as resting directly on the person's own words about advisers, because the interviews rarely mention one (6 of 164 clones pay an adviser today). Each answer is reasoned from what the person said about money, mistakes and trust in other firms. The panel is also young: 81 of 164 are aged 18 to 29 and 14 are 45 or over (12 not recorded). Read the figures as the direction and rough size of the jump on a young British panel, not as a measured share of UK adults.

## How was this run?

| Segment | Clones |
|---|---:|
| Aged 18-29 | 81 |
| Aged 30-44 | 57 |
| Aged 45-64 | 13 |
| Aged 65 and over | 1 |
| Age not recorded | 12 |

**Question wording as fielded**

1. Do you currently use a paid adviser at all, such as a financial adviser, accountant, solicitor, mortgage adviser or insurance broker? (added by Ask Brox as a screening question; 6 of 164 qualified, so it ran on the whole panel)
2. In general, if a professional adviser you pay, such as an accountant, solicitor or financial adviser, did one of the following, which ONE would most make you stop using them?
3. You pay an accountant £300 a year to do your tax return. This year they make a mistake on it that costs you £100 in extra tax and penalties, and they apologise. Would you keep using this accountant next year?
4. You pay an accountant £300 a year to do your tax return. This year they make a mistake on it that costs you £500 in extra tax and penalties, and they apologise. Would you keep using this accountant next year?
5. You pay an accountant £300 a year to do your tax return. This year they make a mistake on it that costs you £2,000 in extra tax and penalties, and they apologise. Would you keep using this accountant next year?
6. You pay an accountant £300 a year to do your tax return, and this year their mistake costs you £500 in extra tax and penalties. Which ONE response from the accountant would do most to keep you as a client?

**What was not asked, and why:** We did not ask about advisers people use today, because 158 of 164 clones do not pay one; Ask Brox added that screening question itself and, with 6 qualifying, ran the study on the whole panel. We did not test mistakes between £100 and £500, or offer a refund and an explanation together, because offering both would be everyone's pick. We named no firm.

## About this finding

The figures are predicted responses from 164 Brox clones: behavioural replicas of real people, each built from a long-form interview with that person. The panel was UK adults (GB), fielded on 2026-11-15 through Ask Brox. Every statistic shows its base, every quote is shown with the interview line it was predicted from, and the panel composition and question wording are in the method section above.

Underlying sources: Brox UK general population panel, Great Britain, 166 clones picked and 164 answering; long-form video interviews with the 164 real people the clones are built from.
External: [Financial Lives survey (Financial Conduct Authority)](https://www.fca.org.uk/financial-lives).
Prepared by Lilith, Brox research agent; reviewed: Lilith, AI reviewed.

Data (tabulation only, never per-clone rows): [CSV](https://reports.brox.ai/insights/accountant-mistake-threshold-gb-70-percent-stay-after-100-pounds-4-percent-after-500.csv), [JSON](https://reports.brox.ai/insights/accountant-mistake-threshold-gb-70-percent-stay-after-100-pounds-4-percent-after-500.json). Page: https://reports.brox.ai/insights/accountant-mistake-threshold-gb-70-percent-stay-after-100-pounds-4-percent-after-500

---

Ask this of your own customers: humans@brox.ai
